Review: “FBP: Federal Bureau of Physics, Vol. 1: The Paradigm Shift”

Rodriguez and Renzi are a perfect match for the psychotropic imagery of "FBP".

Rodriguez and Renzi are a perfect match for the psychotropic imagery of “FBP”.

With memorable images by Robbi Rodriguez that are ready to burst off the pages, and the exuberant pop palette of Rico Renzi, the first volume of “FBP: Federal Bureau of Physics” boasts one of the most exciting art teams of the past year. Unfortunately, the stale characterization and dialogue can’t pull what ought to be a fun series out of the depths of mediocrity.

Writer Simon Oliver has some seriously original ideas gestating within the pages of “FBP: Federal Bureau of Physics, Vol. 1: The Paradigm Shift”, but they are bogged down by characters we struggle to care about and structuring that begs for another draft to smooth things out.

“The Paradigm Shift” introduces readers to a world where the impossible becomes possible and the laws of gravity and physics aren’t as rigid as we know them to be. This is where the Federal Bureau of Physics comes in. This is a government agency tasked with investigating extraordinary occurrences like college students floating above their campus, phantom cities appearing in the skies above a heavily inhabited metropolitan, and worm holes that open doors to other realities. Again, Oliver develops a compelling reality in “FBP”, but he doesn’t spend the same energy on the rest of his book.

The weakness of “FBP” is in its characters. Oliver’s dialogue is wooden and his characterization is flat. He introduces two main characters, FBP Agents Adam Hardy and Rosa Reyes, in this seven-chapter opening volume, and their mysterious backstories certainly add some nice layers, but nothing very interesting is done with them to make readers care one way or the other. It isn’t that they’re unlikable, they just aren’t given anything particularly captivating to say. In an early scene, Adam shows up late for work and is warned by his partner, Jay, that their boss is upset:

Jay: Adam, look out, the Jefe’s on a warpath.
Adam: Thanks for the warning.
Cicero: Agent Hardy. So kind of you to join us, and only ninety minutes late…
Adam: Car trouble.
Cicero: I guess that would explain the lipstick on your cheek.
Adam: Long story.
Cicero: They usually are… save it for later…

Most of the dialogue in “FBP” is similarly wooden. I found myself paging through the book repeatedly to re-read Adam’s scenes and finally walked away not feeling much for the character. Rodriguez and Renzi are left to do the heavy lifting by enlivening the story with exciting images and terrific character designs.

Rodriguez and Renzi are completely unrestrained in the stunning "Bubbleverse" scenes.

Rodriguez and Renzi are completely unrestrained in the stunning “Bubbleverse” scenes.

Rodriguez brings a sketchy animated style that is almost reminiscent of Chuck Jones, but it is certainly distinct enough to call the artist’s work unique. His characters are attractive and filled with emotion; Rodriguez has a strong sense for body language and easily conveys rage, lust, disappointment, anger, confusion, or whatever is required from Oliver’s script.

On top of Rodriguez’s fantastic images lies the uninhibited colors of Renzi, a colorist whose funky sensibility gives the book its limitless visual energy. One of the book’s best sequences is when Adam and Jay are sent to the “Bubbleverse” (the aforementioned phantom city) to bring back a wealthy entrepreneur who may be on the lam. Renzi uses muted colors at first to illustrate that the heroes are no longer in Kansas. For the most part, the inhabitants of the “Bubbleverse” are drawn with minimal lines, most of their characteristics are suggested by Renzi’s colors.

Halfway through the book, Oliver and Rodriguez introduce us to Agent Rosa Reyes in a by-the-numbers sequence in which Rosa doesn’t allow a Caucasian administrative assistant to get away with suggesting that Rosa might be an applicant for a custodial position. The scene begins with this dialogue:

Admin: I don’t think they’re hiring in clerical, but they may be in the maintenance department, I can call human resources…
Rosa: No, you misunderstand… I’m not here to apply, I already have a job…
Admin: You do? Oh, I’m sorry, I just assumed…
Rosa: That naturally a Hispanic woman would only be employed in a cleaning capacity.
Admin: …oh.
Rosa: I suggest you call Special Agent Cicero.
Admin: And why’s that?
Rosa: Because his new field agent is here… Agent Rosa Reyes.

I’m not sure why Oliver didn’t just throw an exclamation point at the end of that histrionic last line since it would have fit the tone of the scene. The writer doesn’t include Rosa’s opening sentence because there’s nothing reasonable that would have caused the dialogue that followed. She wouldn’t have said “I’m here about a job” or asked “Do you have any openings?” What exactly did the administrative assistant “misunderstand”?

Scenes like this made me wonder why Oliver’s editor didn’t have the writer turn in a more polished script. I believe the verbal altercation between Rosa and the admin could have worked, but not as it was written here. In a scene later in “FBP”, a female criminal tells Rosa, “Behind the badge and vow, Agent Reyes, we’re more alike than you’d care to admit.” If you’re going to use the “we’re the same, you and me” line, it needs to be backed up with something substantive or it comes off as exactly what it is: a cliché.

Despite all of this, “FBP: Federal Bureau of Physics” does have numerous positives. Of course there’s the memorable imagery from Rodriguez and Renzi, an artistic team who I am hopeful will work together for years to come. Oliver’s story, the world he’s created, and the backstory he’s come up with for Adam and Rosa, are all strong. Unfortunately, it’s the lack of attention to characterization that brings “FBP” down again and again.

Grade: C

FBP: Federal Bureau of Physics Vol. 1: The Paradigm Shift
Written by: Simon Oliver
Art: Robbi Rodriguez
Colors: Rico Renzi
Letters: Steve Wands, Jared K. Fletcher
Publisher: Vertigo
Original Publication Date: July 2013
Pages: 160 pages

You can find this book at one of the following recommended retailers:
CheapGraphicNovels.com
comiXology.com
InStockTrades.com

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Basic HTML is allowed. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

%d bloggers like this: